Plymouth County Commissioners Approve $850K for Brockton City Hall

Confront Heating “Calamity” at Hingham Court

PLYMOUTH - Dec. 4, 2025 - The Plymouth County Commissioners authorized a redirection of $850,000 in American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds to cover construction overruns at Brockton City Hall and approved an emergency $331,000 HVAC overhaul to prevent a winter catastrophe at Hingham District Court.

The Full Story

In a meeting defined by significant fiscal outlays, the Commissioners moved quickly to support the City of Brockton. County Treasurer Tom O’Brien reported that the city had decided not to pursue a previously funded project and requested to transfer those funds to address cost overruns at the newly renovated City Hall. O’Brien noted the project was “pretty successful” and that the $850,000 transfer would “take one of the burdens off of their shoulders.” The board unanimously approved the transfer [21:31].

A more contentious discussion emerged regarding the Hingham District Court. County Administrator Frank Basler described a critical situation with the building’s 50-year-old steam boiler, which he stated is “past repair.” Basler proposed a $331,000 project to replace the boiler and install heat pumps, utilizing state incentives for energy efficiency. He warned that if the boiler failed during the winter, the court could lose “weeks and months” of operation [29:41].

Commissioner Greg Hanley, participating remotely, raised concerns about the long-term operational costs of switching to electric heat pumps versus sticking with natural gas. “It’s one thing to use the incentives to purchase and install; it’s another thing when those bills start coming due,” Hanley cautioned [34:14]. He urged the administration to consult with National Grid to ensure natural gas wasn’t a more cost-effective option for the specific infrastructure.

The Board ultimately found a middle ground, voting to authorize the project immediately to prevent a winter failure, while amending the motion to require a concurrent review of utility options as requested by Hanley [38:32].

In other business, the Commissioners approved a partnership expansion for the Mobile Integrated Health program. The new Memorandum of Understanding with Beth Israel Deaconess is expected to increase the number of patients served by 25-35%, allowing more residents to recover at home rather than in the hospital [16:34].

Finally, the Board voted to approve a holiday stipend for county employees, though they explicitly excluded themselves from the payout. Commissioner Hanley abstained from the vote to avoid any appearance of impropriety, noting that his brother is employed by the Treasurer’s office. The stipend was characterized as a reward for the workforce’s loyalty during leaner times, specifically the years of wage freezes and furloughs that helped stabilize the County’s books.

“It’s not lost on me, in the context of municipal governments having significant budgetary challenges... that Plymouth County’s smart, conservative budgetary practices have enabled us to be able to do this for our employees.” — Jared Valanzola, Chair [05:42].

Why It Matters

For Brockton taxpayers, the approval ensures the completion of the City Hall project without requiring new local appropriation. For the region, the Hingham District Court decision highlights the tension between adopting green energy (heat pumps) and managing long-term utility costs, a balancing act every municipality is currently facing. Furthermore, the Mobile Integrated Health expansion directly impacts hospital capacity, freeing up beds for emergencies by treating more patients at home.

---

Official Minutes & Data

Key Motions & Votes

• Motion: To approve a transfer of $850,000 in ARPA funds to the City of Brockton.

  • Moved By: Commissioner Sandra Wright

  • Outcome: Passed Unanimously

  • Vote: 3-0 (Roll Call: Hanley, Wright, Valanzola) ([21:31])

• Motion: To approve $331,000 for Hingham District Court HVAC repairs, amended to include due diligence with National Grid regarding energy options.

  • Moved By: Commissioner Sandra Wright (Amended by Hanley)

  • Outcome: Passed Unanimously

  • Vote: 3-0 (Roll Call: Hanley, Wright, Valanzola) ([38:32])

• Motion: To approve an extension of the agreement for the Mobile Integrated Health Program.

  • Moved By: Commissioner Sandra Wright

  • Outcome: Passed Unanimously

  • Vote: 3-0 (Roll Call: Hanley, Wright, Valanzola) ([14:54])

• Motion: To approve a holiday stipend for eligible County employees (excluding Commissioners).

  • Moved By: Commissioner Sandra Wright

  • Outcome: Passed (Hanley Abstained)

  • Vote: 2-0-1 (Hanley abstained due to immediate family employment in the Treasurer’s office) ([03:43])

Public Comment

• Treasurer’s Report: Treasurer Tom O’Brien reported a strong return of 17.46% on the OPEB (Other Post-Employment Benefits) trust over the last year, earning over $64,000 in a single month against only ~$1,200 in expenses [24:38].

• Registry of Deeds: Register John Buckley noted that while real estate sales volume remains “stuck,” high prices have kept excise revenue strong, putting the registry significantly ahead of revenue estimates [12:30].

What’s Next

• Next Meeting: Scheduled for December 18, 2025, potentially moving to 11:00 AM to accommodate a holiday lunch.

• Action Item: Administrator Basler to proceed with Hingham Court contracts while consulting National Grid per Commissioner Hanley’s directive.

---

Source Video: Plymouth County