Subscribe now

The Full Story

The goals, linked from the agenda as Appendix A, were listed for discussion only.

The draft commits to five power standards drawn from the standards superintendents must follow: evaluation, data-informed decision-making, fiscal systems, communication and continuous learning. It then sets four goals aligned with the district improvement plan.

A professional practice goal commits the superintendent to support administrators in consistently implementing four foundational instructional strategies, the focus the district settled on last year. Two student learning goals mirror the improvement plan’s STAR benchmark work in English language arts and math. Raab said one of those goals mistakenly limits the STAR target to grades 2 through 5 and will be amended to grades 2 through 10 to match the district-wide work.

The fourth goal covers the district’s new SEA (Support, Engagement, and Advocacy) department, which places health and wellness, PE and health, and counseling under one central-office department. It also covers the district’s holistic assessment, known as the HSA, which the district will keep this year while deciding whether to continue using it.

Before the goals were walked through, Maria Fenwick said that, by her understanding, once the superintendent selects indicators, those are the only ones the committee evaluates that year, and urged anyone who wants others included to say so now.

I guess the first question is for your SMART goal, I was surprised that it felt like there was no outcome, like measurable outcome.
— Carey Borkoski, School Committee 30:11

Raab said principals could help collect the objectives work and evaluations they are doing with staff.

Carey Borkoski also questioned the HSA, saying that, by her understanding, a measure behind a building principal’s goal comes from one or two student questions, and asked whether social-emotional learning is being implemented consistently before outcomes are measured.

Raab said that part of the goal could be rewritten. Erika McMahon also asked for a concise year-to-year summary of what the assessment shows and what the district does in response.

The committee then held a first reading of its own draft goals for 2026-27. They call for growing the audience for the committee’s town updates, office hours and webpage, measured by readership, viewership and participation; timing academic progress reports to when data is available and tracking how spending supports academic progress; and cutting meetings to an average of two hours. That goal would ask departmental presenters to aim for a maximum of 20 minutes.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Park clears two-thirds

After a resident moved the question, the moderator declared the park motion passed by the required two-thirds on a voice vote.

The motion appropriates $3,835,165 to renovate the property at 44 Jericho Road: $835,165 from undesignated fund balance and $3 million in borrowing by the treasurer with Select Board approval, reduced by any grants received first.

Select Board member Nico Afanasenko said the board voted 4-1 for the project and that deed restrictions the MBTA placed on the land when the town acquired it in 2010 allow only public open space and recreation. He said design changes cut the estimate from $6 million, a $100,000 grant is already secured and the existing building costs taxpayers $30,000 a year in insurance and utilities.

The only question tonight is whether it’s a beautiful park or a patch of dirt
— Nico Afanasenko, Select Board 33:11

Advisory Committee Vice Chair Missy Seidel said the committee supports a public waterfront space but voted 2-4 against this plan over its cost. She put the town’s total investment at just over $7 million, counting $2.5 million already invested, the $3.8 million request and an estimated $742,000 to borrow $3 million at 4.5% over 10 years. She said a simpler design with more modest paths and plantings would be more fiscally prudent.

Conor Doherty, an Advisory Committee member who said he was speaking as a resident, rejected the board’s park-or-dirt framing and said the boardwalk alone costs $1 million.

I think we can still provide an incredible, beautiful seaside park that doesn’t cost the town three million in borrowing and a lack of flexibility for CPC
— Conor Doherty 1:05:35

A Community Preservation Committee representative said the CPC voted unanimously for the project and, despite disliking borrowing, saw it as the only way to finish a 16-year effort. Berry Kurland, chair of the Economic Development Commission, said it voted unanimously in support, arguing the park would draw visitors to harbor businesses.

The finance director, Nancy Holt, said the park debt would take 10 years to repay and would reduce CPC money for other projects, though at least $1 million a year should remain available, depending on the Gates vote.

The town administrator said the revetment work accounts for about $400,000. He also said added parking along Jericho Road, beyond the design’s 20 spaces, would be a separate, later project.

Gates Apartments

The Gates motion drew no speakers from the floor, and the moderator declared it passed by a two-thirds majority. It appropriates $5 million in Community Preservation money for the Gates Apartments, which the Grantham Group plans as 63 affordable senior apartments at the Old Gates School site. The motion draws $587,235 from the Community Housing Reserve and roughly $413,000 from fiscal 2027 estimated receipts and authorizes $4 million in borrowing.

Select Board Vice Chair James Gilmore said the $5 million is the only town money for a roughly $33 million building, with the balance to come from the state and the developer, and that residents will not see real activity at the site for at least a year. The Select Board voted 4-1 in favor.

Seidel said the Advisory Committee voted 5-1 in favor, citing the need for affordable housing and what she described as a one-year safe harbor from new 40B applications; the lone dissent concerned how long the money could be tied up during permitting. A CPC representative likened the $5 million to a poker ante that positions the project for other funding.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

The memorandum of agreement with Fire Fighters Union Local 1464 covers FY28 through FY30 and provides a 3% raise in each year. Town negotiators first sought a one-year deal to give the budget certainty. Talks then moved to two years, so a new fire chief would have time in the job after the current chief ages out in August, and the union then proposed three years to keep the contract on its regular schedule.

The town’s labor counsel puts recent three-year contract awards at 8% to 12%, the board was told. The agreement also adds an insurance opt-out the town has been writing into its union contracts. An employee who leaves the town health plan receives $6,000 for a family plan or $3,000 for an individual plan, which still saves the town about $14,000 for each family plan dropped. Employees must show other coverage and cannot move onto a spouse’s town plan. Last year the town’s employer share of health insurance for this unit alone topped $400,000.

The FY28 capital plan was a presentation, not a vote; the chair called it a preview. The town administrator’s recommendation goes next to the Capital Budget Committee, which begins meeting the following night. Departments have $151 million in capital requests over the next five years, much of it for water and sewer.

The plan keeps borrowing down, with two exceptions: $594,000 for firefighter air packs, backed by a $390,000 grant, and $3 million toward a $3.5 million temporary raw water intake and dredging of the reservoir, with the other half-million in other articles. The presentation said the work would improve water quality and add storage. Most of the plan draws on free cash; $3.7 million was cited.

They had another 4.2 million for the water tank. I rejected that, told them to go back to the drawing board, get some better numbers because that keeps going up and up and up without any real reason that I can see.
— Jim Boudreau, Town Administrator, presenting the FY28 recommended capital plan 23:30

The recommendation also includes the seventh year of the town’s facilities plan at almost $900,000, plus fire department turnout gear, hoses and a new ambulance. The presentation cited $400,000 dedicated to sidewalks this year, starting on Stockbridge Road once its design is updated. It warned that higher local receipt estimates will affect next year’s free cash and that enterprise borrowing must be weighed against rates. A budget presentation and FY28 operating budget recommendations are due at the board’s next meeting.

The board unanimously approved what the docket calls a super conservation restriction, under Chapter 184, Sections 31-33 of the Massachusetts General Laws, on eight town properties: Crosbie-Appleton, Damon, Wade-Lind, Mirarchi-Scituate-Reservoir, Wolfe-Jackson, Higgins-MacAllister off Holly Crest Road, Hubbell and Bound Brook. The town bought the land years ago; the restriction makes its protection permanent after more than 10 years of work by the Conservation Commission with the state and Wildlands Trust. Freya Schlegel recused herself before the discussion.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

The forecast came from the town’s financial forecast committee of school, Select Board and finance officials, which met the Friday before. Superintendent Dr. Thomas Raab told the School Committee that fiscal 2028 will be a struggle.

On revenue, the town is not seeing the new growth it once did. New growth ran close to $2 million through fiscal 2024; the projection now is $700,000 or $800,000. On costs, the district is facing vocational technical school tuitions that were not fully budgeted, employee health insurance increases of 8%, 9% and 10% over the last couple of years, and a Plymouth County retirement assessment rising 10% or 11% a year until it ends in fiscal 2032.

Under a longstanding agreement, the schools receive two-thirds of what is left after shared costs are subtracted and the town receives one-third. Even with that split, the schools are looking at about $400,000 more next year, compared with increases of 4% in recent years.

Raab has sent administrators a memo freezing the fiscal 2027 budget and shared the same memo with all staff. In practice, 20% of the expense budget is being held in reserve: a department with a $5,000 line can spend down to $1,000 and no further. The superintendent cited an unknown winter after last year’s heavy overtime, and said money left in revolving accounts can roll forward into fiscal 2028.

The town does not want to be in this position, but we are. And I think we have to come out early and say it and be honest and then commit to a transparent process.
— Thomas Raab, Superintendent 1:29:51

Over the next couple of weeks, department chairs and principals will build fiscal 2028 budgets two ways: level funded, with no increase, and level services, the cost of keeping things as they are. The superintendent expects the final number to land somewhere in the middle. The district holds a public budget hearing in January and town meeting is in April.

The squeeze has already reached the capital plan. The capital planning committee, meeting last week, kept a $400,000 replacement of the floor in the high school’s small gym in the fiscal 2028 plan and pushed back a project of about $1.9 million to improve the high school’s HVAC system, primarily to serve the second floor.

The committee previewed fiscal 2027 budget transfers it will vote on at its next meeting. Gas utilities would rise $115,000, electricity $22,000 and rubbish collection $24,000. Teacher salaries would increase $98,893, mainly for lane changes, and guidance salaries $72,610 to correct an error. Private school tuitions would drop $260,257 as expanded in-district special education programs keep more students in the district. The overall total is unchanged.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Neither can be covered out of cash on hand. The park would draw $3,835,165 in Community Preservation money, $3 million of it borrowed. The Gates Apartments commitment splits $587,000 from the community housing reserve and $413,000 from estimated receipts, with $4 million borrowed to reach $5 million. It is only the second time in 22 or 23 years the Community Preservation Committee has borrowed, and both articles need a two-thirds vote at town meeting.

The project had been through months of public meetings and five or six return appearances, Community Preservation Committee Chair Dan Fennelly said, and nobody raised objections until the advisory committee voted against it. Early estimates ran past $6 million before redesign brought the request down. The plan covers a boardwalk, a kayak launch, native plantings, ADA-accessible paths, flood storage and stormwater management, and the town is pursuing grants it hopes to have by year’s end, which would come back to the committee and lower its share. The borrowing is written for 10 years.

Public comment ran against it. Lynda Ferguson said restaurant expansion and outdoor seating have added demand for about 100 harbor parking spaces and called the park a want rather than a need the town should borrow for. Vice Chair James Gilmore replied that the construction figure in front of the board that night was $3,835,000. Chair Susan Harrison called harbor access a need in a coastal community where residents should not have to own a boat to reach the water, and said the borrowed money cannot pay for a parking lot.

I think that the design is not the correct design for the space. I think the town and the residents have plenty of access to the harbor, and I think that the board should hold off on this.
— resident Jennifer Kuhn speaking by Zoom 1:17:00

The Gates Apartments plan demolishes only the central building at the former junior high and replaces it with a 64,000-square-foot building holding 63 one-bedroom elderly apartments, a visiting nurse office and a community room, in a project budgeted at $33 million. Every unit would land in the subsidized housing inventory, bringing Scituate close to 7% and giving the town safe harbor to turn away new 40B applications — but not until the project itself is approved, six months to a year out. Member Nico Afanasenko argued the town will fund it eventually and should get out in front of it; Freya Schlegel objected to borrowing while traffic, historical and playing-field questions are unsettled.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

The School Committee finalized a multi-month naming process for the new elementary building scheduled to open in September 2027. The committee began deliberations by winnowing three finalist names—Daniel Ward, Inez Haynes Irwin, and Satuit—using an elimination round. After Ward was eliminated, the committee advanced Irwin and Satuit to a final runoff.

The choice prompted passionate debate among members over town representation and identity. Committee member Erika McMahon advocated for Inez Haynes Irwin, emphasizing that the district currently has no public school named directly after an accomplished woman.

“I keep coming back to the idea that we’re naming a school and it’s a place where generations of Scituate children will learn not only about themselves, but the community that they’re part of. And I love the idea that children will could potentially grow up and learn about who Inez Irwin was from the perspective of having lived in their town, loved their town and led change about what’s possible for generations of people who came after her.” — Erika McMahon, School Committee Member at 0:14:30

Member Carey Borkoski also backed Irwin, pointing to student research highlighting her contributions as a suffragist and writer. Vice Chair Maria Fenwick and Chair Nicole Brandolini spoke in favor of Satuit, quoting student project findings that emphasized how an inclusive, place-based name reflects the Native Americans who inhabited the region and connects to the brook running into Scituate Harbor. Brandolini added that community correspondence and five separate student group presentations heavily favored Satuit. The committee voted 3-2 to name the school Satuit, with Brandolini, Fenwick, and Secretary Janice Lindblom voting yes, and Borkoski and McMahon voting no.

In other major business, Superintendent Tom Raab delivered the latest updates on the district’s Athletics Corrective Action Plan following a spring Title IX audit. Raab presented an implementation matrix with over 50 specific deliverables organized across the fall, winter, and spring athletic seasons. The plan tracks coaching handbooks, uniform replacement cycles, equitable facility scheduling, and expanded volunteer programs. Raab also announced that a Booster Night workshop will take place on Tuesday, September 29, at Gates Commons in Scituate Middle School to review 501(c)(3) standards and donation policy compliance with all athletic booster officers.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

The Scituate Select Board faced a packed agenda on Tuesday night, balancing high-dollar long-term municipal investments with downtown community events.

Leading the policy agenda was a presentation by Capital Planning Committee Chair Michael Gibson on recommendations for the October 19, 2026 Special Town Meeting warrant. The headlining item is the proposed indoor police firing range, returning before voters after falling just short of the required two-thirds borrowing threshold at the April Annual Town Meeting with roughly 61–62% approval. Gibson explained that the project estimate has climbed roughly $200,000 to $2.73 million due to escalating costs.

Town officials outlined two funding pathways: either borrowing the entire $2.73 million sum or utilizing a split package consisting of $1.2 million in borrowing and $1.53 million from free cash. Gibson emphasized that debt service could be accommodated within the town’s existing $2 million borrowing envelope without increasing taxes as older municipal debt retires. Town Administrator Jim Boudreau stressed that modern tactical training is impossible under current arrangements at outside facilities.

“Took my pistol and I did very well. And then the range officer gave me a ballistic shield, turned off the lights, put on strobes, and said, ‘Now reach around and walk through the door and see how very well [you do].’ Scenario-based... those are the types of things that we can’t really do right now.” — Jim Boudreau, Town Administrator

Board members agreed that the project requires clearer public outreach ahead of Town Meeting to ease community concerns regarding multi-town usage and operational control. The Capital Planning Committee also unanimously recommended $57,600 to replace a totaled DPW truck, saving over $10,000 by salvaging existing plow equipment. Formal board votes on Town Meeting warrant recommendations were deferred until all five members could participate.

In labor negotiations, Human Resources Director Bob Clark presented a finalized three-year Memorandum of Agreement with MASSCOP Local 461 covering FY27 through FY29. The contract provides across-the-board cost-of-living adjustments of 2.5% in each of the three years. Additionally, it restructures overtime into base wages for “5 and 2” administrative personnel and expands specialist stipends ($250 to $2,500 annually) for evidence, K-9, and domestic violence officers.

Significantly, the contract includes an additional 1.0% wage increase in Year 2 tied directly to the union’s agreement to implement outward-facing in-car dashboard cameras. Town Administrator Boudreau noted the technology protects both the public and officers during motor vehicle stops and OUI investigations. The board unanimously ratified the agreement and congratulated Clark on his upcoming retirement set for December 16.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

With project construction timelines requiring an official name registered by late September, the Scituate School Committee spent the bulk of its Monday evening meeting vetting naming options for the district’s new consolidated elementary school. The facility will consolidate Cushing and Hatherly elementary schools into a single campus.

Superintendent Dr. Tom Raab delivered a detailed presentation on the findings of the naming task force, which convened on August 18 following a community feedback period. Over the summer, the district solicited community suggestions through an open input form that generated 99 digital submissions and two handwritten letters. The task force reaffirmed earlier decisions to avoid carrying over the names “Cushing” or “Hatherly” into the main building title, opting instead to honor both former leaders with permanent memorial plaques inside the new facility’s main lobby.

Raab presented five options to the committee: two newly prioritized choices recommended by the task force—the Bates Sisters and Daniel Ward—alongside three preexisting finalists: Inez Haynes Irwin, Venus Manning, and Satuit (with Cold Brook noted as an English translation).

In his review of the new entries, Raab outlined the history of Irish immigrant Daniel Ward, who arrived in Scituate in the mid-19th century after identifying harvestable Irish moss (carrageenan) along the coastline. Ward founded the local mossing industry, which provided vital livelihoods for generations of Irish families fleeing the potato famine and spurred the region’s winter life-saving crews. The Bates Sisters (Abigail and Rebecca) gained renown for reportedly deterring a British naval landing party in September 1814 by playing a fife and drum from the Scituate Light station. However, Raab emphasized that the Bates account contains elements of unverified folklore, despite affidavits later signed in Rebecca Bates’s older years.

During discussion, committee members weighed district naming policies, which prioritize educational significance, inspiration, and regional dignity. Committee members noted reservations about naming an academic facility after folklore rather than verifiable history. Additionally, members pointed out that Venus Manning—while an inspiring figure who achieved financial literacy and supported abolitionist causes while facing discriminatory taxes in the late 18th and early 19th centuries—lived in a section of historic Scituate that is now part of the modern town of Norwell.

“It says a name with educational significance or inspiration should be chosen. ... And so I think similar to Nicole, I’ve been really thinking about the statement that comes before that sentence... which of the five names kind of has the best educational potential or value that could be inspirational to kids in the future.” — Maria Fenwick

Recognizing that voting on five candidates at once could create parliamentary deadlocks, the committee chose to proactively trim the list. The committee voted 5–0 to remove Venus Manning and subsequently voted 5–0 to remove the Bates Sisters. Members also voiced opposition to using the English translation “Cold Brook,” favoring the indigenous name “Satuit” should a geographical name prevail.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Following severe winter storm damage across coastal private marinas earlier this year, Scituate Boat Works experienced severe bottlenecks moving customer vessels between the water, docks, and inland storage lots. The resulting overflow occupied slips around the Scituate Maritime Center, sparking public feedback and prompting harbor officials to formulate a structured operational solution.

Waterways Commission Chairman Dave Dinneen presented the negotiated terms to the Select Board. Under the previous lease, Scituate Boat Works held rights exclusively to the south side of Float A. The newly adopted addendum permits the company to utilize approximately 16 slips—spanning all of Float A and the south side of Float B—during two distinct shoulder-season windows: April 15 through the morning of May 14 in the spring, and October 16 through November 14 in the fall.

“It looks to us, and after having a very good year with these shoulder seasons, it’s just another way to help generate additional revenue... and it helps a partner of ours be able to function a little bit more easily.” — Dave Dinneen, Waterways Commission Chairman

Board members underscored that the designated docks will function strictly as a temporary staging zone rather than a standard marina rental. Select Board Chair Susan Harrison clarified that Boat Works cannot sublet slips, host transient boaters, or permit vessel owners to linger on moored boats. Once an owner arrives, the boat must immediately depart.

In addition to seasonal staging, the board approved an administrative cleanup to Section 9 of the Marine Park Marine Service Center lease. Finance Director Nancy Holt explained that the town will now collect the additional 3% lease payment on a quarterly basis based on prior-year revenue—with a final year-end true-up—eliminating irregular multi-year reporting lags and stabilizing town cash flow.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

District leaders and committee members convened Monday evening to review comprehensive operational and cultural reforms within Scituate High School athletics, an initiative sparked by the independent review delivered by Mr. Granatino’s Title IX assessment earlier in the year. Superintendent Dr. Thomas Raab opened the presentation by acknowledging past shortcomings regarding equitable treatment and culture, offering a direct apology to female athletes and coaching staff.

Athletic Director Scott Paine outlined concrete steps being taken across eleven targeted operational areas. Key changes include transitioning from historical lump-sum athletic budgets to line-item, per-sport budgeting for FY28 to ensure full transparency, centralizing all official coach-student communications onto the ParentSquare platform, guaranteeing all outdoor varsity teams at least two regular-season night games, addressing field encroachment issues by strictly enforcing practice schedules, and instituting standard operating procedures for athletic training room triage and medical coverage. Paine also announced the planned formation of a 16-member Scituate High School Athletic Council comprising administrators, faculty, coaches, parents, and student-athletes to mirror the town’s successful site-based council models.

“The success of our program is determined by student athletes feeling valued, feeling like they belong, and most importantly, feeling appreciated for the hard work and effort they put forth every day.” [02:00:05] — Scott Paine, Athletic Director

School committee members underscored the importance of coupling logistical checklists with meaningful accountability and cultural transformation. Discussions highlighted concerns over the single athletic trainer position—which currently shares duties with the assistant athletic director role—as well as the historic reliance on parent booster groups to fund team supplemental items and volunteer coaches. Under the new policy, booster groups will no longer directly pay stipends to volunteer coaches; instead, any funds will be formally gifted to the district to administer proper payroll compliance and oversight.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

For nearly two years, Scituate officials and residents have grappled with overburdened beach parking lots and out-of-town visitors taking spots without valid stickers. The issue reached a boiling point at town meeting, where voters overwhelmingly signaled their desire for a steep penalty, overriding lower proposed increases to demand a full push to the $150 maximum allowed under state law.

Town Administrator Jim Boudreau provided compelling context for the change, reporting that of 293 recent parking tickets issued by police as of late July, 2025 were specifically for failing to display a valid beach sticker. Board members noted that with non-resident beach stickers priced at $350 per season, the previous $50 fine was simply treated as a minor cost of doing business by seasonal visitors.

While board members debated whether a intermediate increase to $125 might ease the transition, the consensus quickly converged on the $150 threshold to honor public sentiment and establish a meaningful deterrent. Department of Public Works crews will apply updated rate stickers to beach parking signage ahead of the August 10 effective date.

“I think we heard loud and clear from the people at town meeting that they wanted it to be higher... This was almost a year and a half ago, two years ago... People are very frustrated with beach parking, and this is probably the most emails I get during my entire time on the select board.” — Susan Harrison, Select Board Chair

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Town Administrator Jim Boudreau opened his administrative report with critical news regarding municipal finances. FEMA notified the town that it is abandoning multiple legacy disaster declaration grants dating back as far as 2012, including projects along Third Cliff. According to Boudreau, the federal agency cited extensive permitting delays—despite past assurances urging the town to proceed—and is now demanding reimbursement or withholding roughly $3 million in anticipated project funding.

The decision not only forces Scituate to cover the direct project costs but also threatens to create cash deficits on the town’s financial books where federal receipts had been anticipated. Scituate is reaching out to state officials, federal legislative delegations, and seven other Massachusetts coastal communities facing identical federal clawbacks to organize a collective response. Select Board members expressed sharp frustration over the sudden policy shift, noting that lengthy multi-year state and federal environmental permitting processes placed the town in an impossible double bind.

“FEMA has been telling us to keep going and now the time is, ‘Well, sorry. We don’t care. We told you to keep going, we’re going to take back the money that you spent.’ So this could be impactful... It also underscores the fact that the state and feds are going to have to make some changes to how they permit repair projects. It should not take 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 years to permanently repair a structure.” — Jim Boudreau, Town Administrator

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

The meeting opened with a somber moment of silence for Chris Matthews, a former Scituate resident and dedicated district outreach director who passed away recently. However, the peaceful mood quickly shifted during the un-agendaged “walk-in” segment, when a large delegation of Turner Road and Sandhills residents stepped forward to address deteriorating safety conditions in their coastal neighborhood.

Matthew Svagdis detailed a June 27 incident where speeding teenagers ran over a possum at 10:00 PM, calling it a symptom of a larger summer influx that has made full-time residency exhausting. Neighbor Joanne White added that absentee owners and short-term rentals are rapidly turning Sandhills into an unregulated entertainment venue.

Carol Sullivan-Hanley delivered a fiery testimony, noting she has previously petitioned the traffic committee after witnessing two dogs killed on the road. “I should not have to throw a watering can. I should not have to scream at cars to slow down. It’s ridiculous,” Sullivan-Hanley said, asserting that confusing 20 MPH and 30 MPH signs have done nothing to stop drivers from treating the strip like the “Indy 500”. Adding to the neighborhood’s frustrations, Linda Murphy brought a piece of a burned firework wrapper recovered just ten feet from her wooden deck following a July 3rd “bombing raid,” asking for community outreach and strict signage reminding renters of the state’s strict fireworks fines.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Information Technology Director Mike Minchello presented a stark reality to the board regarding Scituate’s digital spine, comparing the town’s virtual architecture to a series of apartment buildings housing vital municipal operations. Every essential system—including physical security, cyber defenses, and the primary police and fire dispatch databases—relies entirely on these centralized virtual hosts.

The town originally approved $350,000 for the scheduled hardware upgrade based on historical pricing models. However, a massive global surge in AI data center construction has created severe supply chain bottlenecks, causing the market cost of standard 64-gig memory chips to balloon from $4,900 to an unprecedented $42,000 per chip at manufacturer suggested retail prices (MSRP). Minchello warned that Hewlett Packard (HP) management had rejected further discount requests and was prepared to increase overall package pricing by another half-million dollars if the town failed to execute its contract before a strict June 30th vendor expiration date.

“[The vendor is] basically saying, ‘Hey, we’ll give you a quote today, but we can’t guarantee the price until it actually ships.’ Something brand new, never seen this before.” — Mike Minchello, IT Director

Faced with a choice between a high-risk, multi-vendor “budget” option lacking automated data backups, delaying action for a Special Town Meeting, or authorizing the transfer, the board opted to protect municipal operations. Finance Director Nancy Holt confirmed that transferring $134,683 from the town’s solar array revolving fund would safely patch the deficit. The newly secured hardware guarantees a stable six-year operational window capable of absorbing town data growth.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

The newly reorganized Scituate School Committee—which re-elected Nicole Brandolini as Chair, Maria Fenwick as Vice Chair, and tapped Janice Lindblom as Secretary—was quickly thrust into the community spotlight during public comment. Parents voiced deep frustration over findings within a recently completed Title IX athletics audit. Residents criticized the report’s missing budget breakdowns for fiscal years 2025 and 2026, noting that the systemic spending gaps between boys’ and girls’ sports could be far worse than the 10-to-15 percent disparity trend already identified in previous years.

Community members highlighted stark discrepancies in scheduling, match counts, and basic human resources. While the Scituate boys’ golf team regularly secures an 18-match season, the girls’ golf team has historically been restricted to just 10 matches, falling significantly behind neighboring towns like Hingham and Duxbury. Medical safety was also raised as a critical vulnerability; a single athletic trainer is currently forced to divide time between simultaneous events, leaving female athletes unprotected when male varsity sports take scheduling priority.

Superintendent Dr. Tom Raab acknowledged that he deliberately refrained from editing the raw data of the independent report, stating it accurately mirrors the compromised “lived experience” of girls in the district’s athletic program. In response, Raab introduced a preliminary 11-point corrective action plan aimed at reshaping internal communication, standardizing booster club distributions, and transitioning to a transparent “bottom-up” budgeting model.

“This report goes a long way to talk about process and policy, but I still don’t see the people in this... I was a collegiate female athlete, and this report ticked me off because this is the crap I was going through. And I’m way, way older. And this is still going on.” — Committee Member Carey Borkoski

The School Committee pushed Raab to immediately reorganize his draft plan using a strict visual schedule, sorting immediate “low-hanging fruit” from long-term cultural and organizational overhauls. Members also called for direct oversight from a newly proposed Equity and Belongion subcommittee to ensure the plan does not simply sit on a shelf.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Late that afternoon, Massachusetts Secretary of Energy and Environmental Affairs Rebecca Tepper declared a Level 2 Significant Drought for southeastern Massachusetts, Cape Cod, and the Islands region. The declaration follows two years of below-average rainfall, declining streamflows, and dropping groundwater tables across the state. In May alone, the region received only one to three inches of rain, which tracks one and a half to three inches below monthly norms.

Scituate’s local water infrastructure is already reflecting the strain. The municipal reservoir has dropped to a level of plus 0.25 inches—a significant drop from last week’s plus one inch measurement. By comparison, the reservoir sat comfortably at plus seven inches on the exact same date last year.

Under Tier 2 water restrictions, the use of automatic irrigation systems is strictly prohibited. Outdoor watering is limited exclusively to handheld hoses, which are only permitted during the off-peak hours of 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. The Town emphasized that the initial municipal strategy will focus heavily on public education, though enhanced enforcement protocols are being deployed. Officials urged residents to capitalize on the town’s water rebate program, which offers $250 rebates for energy-efficient dishwashers and washing machines, and $150 for WaterSense-certified toilets, to help mitigate structural water demand.

“Under Level 2 severe drought conditions, watering is allowed only with handheld hoses. This means the town is now in Tier 2 water restrictions, with no use of automatic irrigation.” — Town Administrator, Jim Boudreau

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Superintendent Dr. Tom Raab introduced Jeff Granatino to deliver the highly anticipated Title IX assessment. The audit was launched in Fall 2025 following a wave of public complaints regarding disparities between boys’ and girls’ sports. While Granatino emphasized that Scituate boasts state-of-the-art facilities and historically successful programs, his findings exposed severe operational and systemic flaws.

On paper, Scituate meets the federal “safe harbor” standard for substantial proportionality in participation, with female student enrollment at 49.9% and athletic participation at 49.3% over the last five years. However, the investigation uncovered critical imbalances across the “equity walk” evaluation.

A major point of contention centered on athletic budgeting and the financial opacity surrounding booster clubs. Scituate’s athletic department operates under a rolling historical budget—currently just under $1 million—that simply adds a 2% to 3% increase annually rather than tracking program-specific needs. Granatino’s review discovered a 10% built-in spending discrepancy favoring boys’ programs in the base budget. Compounding this, the district’s business office was completely unable to track exact expenditures by sport, creating a massive accountability gap.

Furthermore, independent booster clubs add an average of $165,000 annually to sports programs without any structural school oversight. Granatino warned that under Title IX law, if a booster club injects significant funds into a boys’ team (such as baseball), the district is legally obligated to provide equivalent resources to the corresponding girls’ team (such as softball). In a striking revelation, the report noted that the football booster club has been directly supplementing coaching stipends outside of the collective bargaining process, bypassing school committee awareness.

Read more

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Project Manager Allison Varanelli of Collins Engineers presented a comprehensive coastal modeling simulation representing a 1% annual chance “100-year storm” under projected sea-level rise conditions. The simulations demonstrated that Cole Parkway and the Mil Wharf area are the community’s primary vulnerabilities, functioning as open entry points that draw flood waters straight toward Front Street. Under 2030 conditions, the storm surge still-water elevation is projected to hit 10.3 feet—over 4 feet higher than the existing lowest bulkheads—expanding into deep water layers by 2050 [01:21:43].

To address these vulnerabilities, engineering teams designed a “Design Flood Elevation” (DFE) threshold of 12 feet to keep downtown dry through a 2050 storm scenario. Two high-level protection alignments were brought forward:

• Inland Protection Alignment (Red Line): This model loops primarily through town-owned property, using retaining walls along Front Street and deployable gates that can be erected within an hour across critical intersections like Old Dock Street. Ground elevations are higher inland, requiring less wall height [01:24:19].

• Water-Side Protection Alignment (Blue Line): This strategy pushes the barrier out to encompass private lands, coastal properties, and the entire Mill Wharf restaurant plaza, providing complete waterfront protection but at a much steeper capital cost and needing dense coordination with private owners [01:26:27].

Board member Nico Afanasenko advocated aggressively for the water-side “blue line,” noting that any compromise line would cause water to push harder into unprotected private zones [01:37:21]. Afanasenko criticized the concurrent Phase A plan to lift the Cole Parkway parking lot to 9 feet instead of the resilient 12 feet, calling out the board’s persistent focus on convenience parking spots over protecting future infrastructure.

“We spend entirely too much time talking about parking and not enough time talking about flooding, because the businesses can’t use parking if the businesses are full of water,” Nico Afanasenko, Select Board [01:40:11].

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

The Scituate School Committee opened its regular session on high-level administrative business, evaluating data compiled by an independent executive consultant tasked with drafting a “Superintendent Candidate Profile”. Dr. Carey Borkoski led the synthesis of the data, which condensed individual assessments from the school board, public feedback, and regional focus groups into seven distinct evaluation categories: communication, collaboration, curriculum, budget/finance, strategic leadership, technical expertise, and overall educational operations.

The evaluation results overwhelmingly validated Dr. Raab’s performance during his interim year. Committee members highlighted his unmatched clarity in budget and finance—noting his background as the district’s former business manager allows him to seamlessly translate complex educational priorities into distinct budget lines that the town can rally behind. The data also praised his soft skills, characterizing him as an “even-keeled,” approachable leader who holds face-to-face office hours and remains highly visible across all grade levels, athletic functions, and neighborhood PTOs.

When evaluating whether to execute a formal, wide-scale external search, the committee performed a strict risk-benefit analysis. Committee member Maria Fenwick noted that typical external recruitment processes provide mere “tiny snippets” of a person’s capability and carry substantial unknown risks. Board members ultimately agreed that Dr. Raab met every localized criteria established by stakeholders. Dr. Borkoski framed the final consensus using a logical margin-of-benefit comparison:

“The economist in me is like, at the margin, what would have to be the benefit of an external candidate to outweigh the benefits of everything I know about Tom? And I couldn’t think of anything... I just can’t make that math work for me.” — Dr. Carey Borkoski

The board will formally request a letter of interest from Dr. Raab, positioning a final permanent appointment vote for their subsequent public meeting.

Read more