Subscribe now

The Override Paradox

The structural budget stress that dominated last week’s newsletter didn’t resolve with the close of FY26 — it deepened. Marshfield voters gave a decisive answer on who should decide, but the fiscal question underneath remains open.

• Marshfield — Rohland Wins Marshfield Select Board Special Election in Decisive Landslide Chris Rohland captured 68.4% of the vote (2,477 votes to Jack Griffin’s 959 and Joe Pecevich’s 185) in the three-way race to fill Trish Simpson’s seat, breaking a months-long board impasse and restoring Marshfield to a functioning three-member Select Board for the first time in over a year.

• Marshfield — Marshfield Names New Town Administrator, Eyes Major Governance Changes and Override Date With Rohland casting the deciding vote, the newly reconstituted board voted 2-1 to appoint Weymouth Chief of Staff Edward Langill as Town Administrator, set a September 1 date for a $7 million operational override election, and forwarded two charter amendments — expanding the Select Board to five members and creating a Finance Director position — to the Legislature, both over Eric Kelley’s continued dissent.

Governance Fractures: Who’s in Charge Here?

The most consequential stories of the week weren’t about money — they were about authority, and what happens when the org chart doesn’t match the power map.

• Stoughton — The Lockout in Stoughton: A Police Chief, a Town Manager, and the Ghost of Sandra Birchmore In a three-week escalation that moved from closed-door personnel meetings to a Norfolk Superior Court lawsuit, Police Chief Donna McNamara was effectively ousted by Town Manager Thomas Calter without ever being formally placed on administrative leave — a charter ambiguity her attorney is characterizing as constructive discharge and gender-based harassment, while hundreds of residents rallied publicly for her reinstatement and the Select Board held an emergency session to place both of them on paid leave while they investigate.

• Hull — Hull Select Board Votes to Separate Light Plant from Joint Facility Grant, Approves $110K Feasibility Study In back-to-back 3-2 votes during a fractious joint session with the Municipal Light Board, the Select Board pulled the Hull Municipal Light Plant out of a pending CZM coastal resilience grant application for a $45 million joint facility at 9 Nantasket Ave — over the Town Manager’s warning that the charter gives her control of grant applications and facilities — and simultaneously directed the Light Plant to proceed with a $110,000 feasibility study for staying at its current 15 Edgewater Road location, where its share of the joint facility would have been $14.4 million before any BRIC grant offsets.

• Hanson — Hanson Select Board Backs Conceptual Trade-Off to Secure Two-Thirds Voting Veto in Whitman-Hanson Regional School Agreement Hanson’s board voted to accept absorbing an estimated $54,000–$65,000 annually in non-mandated busing costs into the regional assessment starting in FY28, in exchange for a mandatory two-thirds vote threshold on major Whitman-Hanson Regional School Committee decisions — a structural concession explicitly designed to eliminate what member Frank Milisi called “town line votes” on capital debt, superintendent contracts, and school closures, pending legal and DESE review before Town Meeting.

What’s in the Water: The PFAS Billing Reckoning

South Shore News’s ongoing PFAS investigation moved this week from exposure mapping to cost accounting — and the numbers demand sustained attention from every finance committee on the South Shore.

• Regional — What’s in the Water: A South Shore News Investigation The second installment of the regional PFAS investigation finds that disclosed treatment costs already exceed $200 million across the South Shore — Middleborough ($80M+), Duxbury ($43M), Hanover ($32M), Abington-Rockland ($26M), Norwell ($18M), Scituate ($20M) — climbing toward $350 million once broader water-system overhauls are included, with settlement and grant funding covering only a small fraction: Hanover’s $1 million settlement share against a $32 million project means ratepayers are on the hook for roughly 97 cents of every dollar, and the 3M settlement claims deadline fell July 31.

• Duxbury — Technical Glitch Sparks $42,000 Water Bill Shock as Duxbury Selectboard Confronts Meter Errors, PFAS, and Powder Point Bridge Delay A 22-year meter tracking failure produced a $42,239.88 bill for West Street resident Nigel Bird — ultimately abated to $892.02 after he performed his own forensic accounting across two decades of land records — while a second abatement request involving 451,000 gallons of unaccounted usage was tabled pending a comprehensive departmental review, underscoring systemic meter and radio reliability problems that will complicate the town’s already-fraught PFAS rate increases.

  Share

Federal Clawbacks and Capital Risk

The assumption that signed federal commitments are bankable is taking a beating across the region.

• Scituate — FEMA Pulls $3 Million in Coastal Reimbursements, Leaving Scituate on the Hook FEMA abruptly walked away from multiple legacy disaster declaration grants dating to 2012, citing permitting delays that the town argues were caused by mandatory state and federal environmental review timelines — leaving Scituate facing a $3 million deficit on projects where federal receipts had already been booked, while Town Administrator Jim Boudreau confirmed at least seven other Massachusetts coastal communities face identical clawbacks and are organizing a collective response.

• SSVT — Favorable Sub-Bids and Lifted Cease-and-Desist Order Keep SSVT Building Project Moving Forward South Shore Vocational Technical’s new school construction project caught a rare break: a Conservation Commission cease-and-desist order triggered by unauthorized subcontractor wetland crossings was lifted with no cost impact to the district, and sub-trade bids across all 14 categories came in below budget expectations — keeping the critical August 17 foundation pour on schedule.

• Hingham — Hingham Previews Fall Special Town Meeting to Tackle Multi-Million Dollar School Roofs and $70M Light Plant Project The Select Board announced an October 28 Special Town Meeting to pursue full borrowing authorization for MSBA Accelerated Repair Program roof replacements at Plymouth River and South Elementary schools (36.89% state reimbursement rate), a scope adjustment on the $3.3 million high school feasibility design authorization, and a reintroduced $70 million borrowing for Hingham Municipal Lighting Plant transmission and substation upgrades — debt service on the latter funded through ratepayers, not the levy.

School Budgets and Facilities

MSBA pipelines are active across multiple towns simultaneously, compressing the governance and procurement calendar for districts from Norwell to Plymouth.

• Norwell — Norwell School District Advances Key Policies and Prepares for Major Facility Feasibility Study Following its entry into the MSBA feasibility study phase, the district received RFS responses for an Owner’s Project Manager on July 15 and expects to present a recommendation to the full School Building Committee this week ahead of state approval in September — running the OPM procurement on a tight summer timeline.

• Plymouth — North Plymouth Residents Press Select Board on Pulte Traffic, Water Mains, and 40B Mandates “On the Road” At a packed Cold Spring Elementary gymnasium, residents pressed the Select Board on the stalled Pulte 300-unit Chapter 40B development (all infrastructure improvements on hold pending ZBA appeal), a fall water main replacement on Cherry Street, a $2.5 million intersection reconstruction pushed to summer 2027, and the newly MSBA-accepted Hedge Elementary feasibility study — projected at a 53% reimbursement rate — exploring potential consolidation with Cold Spring.

• Norwell — Norwell Explores Groundbreaking Supported Housing Model to Address Local Need The Select Board heard a presentation from SAIL Homes on a supported-living model for neurodivergent adults — combining smart-home assistive technology with CPA housing funds and state earmarks, as demonstrated in a Scituate retrofit serving eight residents — and expressed interest in exploring a similar project within Norwell’s Village Residential Overlay District, a signal worth watching as the town navigates its broader housing obligations.

Economic Development and Private Roads

• Plymouth — Plymouth Lays Groundwork for Comprehensive Economic Overhaul in Workshop Session In a second installment of its SWOT-analysis-driven workshop series, the Select Board moved to update zoning definitions for commercial corridors to prevent residential encroachment on light industrial land and directed staff to design a “business concierge” position to streamline multi-departmental permitting — a structural acknowledgment that regulatory friction is real and that protecting the non-residential tax base requires proactive land-use management.

Municipal Housekeeping

• Abington — Water Commission Appointments and Bruins Street Hockey Rink Take Center Stage in Abington The Select Board filled two long-vacant seats on the Abington-Rockland Joint Water Works Commission — appointing licensed master plumber Corey Dalton (4-1) and retired Coast Guard Lieutenant Richard Mullen (unanimous) to restore quorum capacity — while approving a licensing agreement with the Boston Bruins Foundation for a new street hockey rink at Arnold Park.

• Marshfield — Marshfield Select Board Rectifies Committee Appointment, Accepts Over $3,900 in Local Donations In a brief interim session before the full board was seated, the Select Board accepted donations totaling over $3,950 to Veterans Services, the Council on Aging, and the Historical Commission, and commended public safety agencies for their management of the Levitate Music & Arts Festival.

• Plymouth County — Heated Plymouth County GOP Forum Sparks Clashes Over Commissioner Pay, Federal ARPA Funds, and Governance Incumbent Commissioner Sandra Wright, challenger Tony O’Brien, and candidate Korey Welch clashed at a WATD forum over O’Brien’s claim that commissioners earn an effective $3,000–$5,000 per hour; Wright defended a turnaround from a 2011 $1 million deficit to a current $1.5 million surplus with zero debt, while all three argued over whether retaining administration of $200 million in ARPA and CARES funds at the county level was sound stewardship or federal liability exposure.

Subscribe now

For over half a century, developers, municipal planners, and Massachusetts homeowners shared a grim, widely acknowledged truth: if your project needed a zoning variance in the Bay State, it was a challenge.

Since the 1950s, Massachusetts maintained what land-use attorneys routinely described as one of the most demanding variance standards in the country. Under the legacy framework of G.L. c. 40A, § 10, a local Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) could grant a variance only under a rigid, three-part conjunctive test: an applicant had to prove a “substantial hardship” arising uniquely from the “soil conditions, shape, or topography” of the land, and prove that relief could be granted without derogating from the intent of the local bylaw. The Supreme Judicial Court (SJC) enforced this test with near-monastic rigor. Hardship was read so narrowly that ordinary dimensional deficiencies — a lot that was simply too small or too narrow — were legally insufficient to support a variance.

The practical result was a hypocritical system. Local boards, eager to permit sensible projects, granted variances fairly often. But because those variances almost never met the SJC’s strict statutory bar, they were instantly vulnerable to being overturned on appeal by a litigious neighbor. The result was a toxic mix of litigation risk, unpredictability, and land-use stagnation.

Then, on July 9, 2026, Governor Maura Healey signed the FY2027 budget — Budget Bill 5555, enacted as Chapter 137 of the Acts of 2026.

While the bill’s headline job was to serve as the Commonwealth’s roughly $63.4 billion Fiscal Year 2027 budget, it also contained a package of “outside sections” (Sections 40 through 49) that quietly executed a systematic overhaul of G.L. c. 40A. Because the changes rode inside a must-pass appropriations bill carrying an emergency preamble, they took effect immediately on signing — a rewrite of the variance rules that housing advocates had sought, and failed to win, for decades.

One important limit: these Chapter 40A changes do not apply in Boston, which zones under its own charter (Chapter 665 of the Acts of 1956). Everything below describes the law for the other 350 cities and towns.

Here is how the change happened, what actually changed, and how it realigns the balance of power between Massachusetts’s home-rule municipalities and the developers trying to build a way out of an acute housing crisis.

I. The History: The Iron Curtain of “Substantial Hardship”

To understand why land-use attorneys are calling these changes a “doctrinal earthquake,” it helps to look at the legal ruins they left behind.

The original Zoning Act established a regime of extreme municipal deference, and over decades SJC case law built a massive evidentiary wall against nearly any form of zoning relief. In Blackman v. Board of Appeals of Barnstable, 334 Mass. 446 (1956), the SJC set the baseline, holding that the power to vary a zoning ordinance “must be sparingly exercised and only in rare instances and under exceptional circumstances.” The companion principle that “no person has a legal right to a variance” runs through this same line of cases and is often quoted from Damaskos v. Board of Appeal of Boston, 359 Mass. 55 (1971).

By the 1980s, the appellate courts had cemented a brutal “conjunctive” checklist. In Kirkwood v. Board of Appeals of Rockport, 17 Mass. App. Ct. 423 (1984), and Guiragossian v. Board of Appeals of Watertown, 21 Mass. App. Ct. 111 (1985), the courts reiterated that a petitioner had to satisfy every statutory criterion under § 10. Fail even one factor — for instance, showing a hardship that was economic rather than physical — and the variance was legally void.

Subsequent rulings closed nearly every imaginable loophole:

• The dimensional trap — Tsagronis v. Board of Appeals of Wareham, 415 Mass. 329 (1993): The SJC confirmed that ordinary dimensional deficiencies, such as inadequate frontage or lot area, do not satisfy the “shape” criterion. If your lot was simply too narrow, you did not qualify.

• The profit rule — Perez v. Board of Appeals of Norwood, 54 Mass. App. Ct. 139 (2002): The court held that a developer’s desire to maximize profit did not constitute “substantial hardship,” and further found that a hardship that was self-inflicted could not support relief.

• Dimensional, not shape — Whelan v. Zoning Board of Appeals of Norfolk, 430 Mass. 1009 (2000): Reinforcing Tsagronis, the SJC held that where a lot’s problem is insufficient frontage and area rather than genuinely unusual shape, no variance is warranted.

For decades this framework functioned as an attrition mechanism. It kept Massachusetts highly preserved, highly suburban, and increasingly unaffordable. Because the statutory bar was so high, almost any multi-family proposal needing even a minor dimensional variance was dead if an abutter chose to sue.

II. The Overhaul: Dismantling the Hardship Bar

Chapter 137 took a sledgehammer to this edifice. It deleted the old, restrictive variance language of G.L. c. 40A, § 10 and replaced it with a flexible “practical difficulty” balancing standard modeled on national land-use trends.

Under the new § 10, a ZBA is now required to grant a variance if it finds that strict enforcement of the local bylaw would result in a “practical difficulty.” The statute directs boards to discard the rigid conjunctive checklist and instead perform a holistic balancing test, weighing:

This is a structural shift. Crucially, the Legislature demoted the classic, near-impossible physical requirements — soil conditions, lot shape, and topography — from mandatory prerequisites to optional factors a board may consider. The new balancing test looks like this:

Weigh: the applicant’s private benefit + the public interest in housing production Against: the detriment to neighborhood health, safety, and welfare

Optional “may consider” factors: soil/shape/topography; financial hardship; whether feasible alternatives exist; and whether the difficulty was self-created.

By inserting “the interest in supporting the production of housing” directly into the balance, the state placed a pro-development thumb on the local scale. A board can no longer deny a variance merely by pointing to a checklist of missing physical anomalies. And by moving financial hardship into the mix, the statute provides a pragmatic baseline for dimensional relief that the old SJC jurisprudence rejected.

Just what "practical difficulty" requires, though, is left deliberately open — and that ambiguity may be the most consequential feature of the whole rewrite. "The legislation doesn't really define what that means, which I think was intentional," said Nick Giaquinto, Norwell’s Director of Planning and Community Development. "It leaves a lot of that judgment to local permitting authorities, at least initially. Over time, as different boards apply the standard and those decisions make their way through the courts, we'll get a much clearer understanding of what the Legislature intended." He called that one of the most interesting aspects of the reforms — a standard whose real meaning will be written, case by case, over years.

III. The Use-Variance Change: Overriding Local Vetoes

The relaxed dimensional standard is a major win for developers, but the budget carried an even bigger surprise: the legalization of residential use variances in almost every community in the state.

Historically, “use variances” — which allow an activity flatly prohibited in a zoning district, such as building apartments in a commercial or industrial zone — were illegal in Massachusetts unless a municipality’s own bylaws expressly opted to permit them. Very few towns did. So developers who wanted to convert obsolete strip malls or empty offices into housing had to win a formal zoning amendment, which in Massachusetts meant running the town-meeting or city-council gauntlet, historically at a two-thirds supermajority.

Chapter 137 bypassed that local bottleneck. The amended § 10 now provides that, except where local bylaws expressly permit use variances, no variance may authorize a non-conforming use other than residential. In other words, the state carved out residential use as a statewide default. Municipalities keep the right to prohibit or permit commercial and industrial use variances, but they can no longer block their ZBAs from granting residential ones.

As Dan Dain of Dain Torpy, the land-use attorney who chaired the Real Estate Bar Association (REBA) committee behind the reforms, put it: “Why are we prohibiting residential in so many places? … Why not encourage municipalities to allow residential use in nonresidential districts?”

Instead of spending a year lobbying town-meeting members for a commercial-to-residential rezoning, a developer can now walk into a ZBA hearing, present a site plan, and argue under the new “practical difficulty” standard that converting an obsolete office park into housing serves the public interest.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

The July 27 meeting commenced with newly elected Select Board member Chris Rohland taking his seat alongside Chair Rick Smith and Board member Eric Kelley, establishing the town’s full board for the first time in several months.

Following public comments, the Board tackled its foremost agenda item: filling the Town Administrator role. The choice came down to two finalists: Edward “Ted” Langill, Chief of Staff in Weymouth, and Peter Caruso, Town Administrator of Millville.

Select Board Chair Rick Smith voiced strong support for Langill, citing his municipal experience in Weymouth and leadership track record.

“I stand in full support of Mr. Langill. I believe that based upon his impressive resume, his impressive experience, the respect that he commands throughout the South Shore, the great work that he’s done in the city of Weymouth... he was able to address many of the questions... in regard to what kind of leader he would be to move forward the agenda and the policy initiatives of this board.” — Rick Smith, Select Board Chair

Member Eric Kelley supported Caruso, raising concerns over Weymouth’s high level of development under Langill’s tenure.

“I think Edward Langill from the city of Weymouth, though he’s done a good job out there... the city of Weymouth is still growing... in regards to more development of apartments and all that... it raises a concern for me, as well as many other residents, in regards to the direction of where Marshfield is going.” — Eric Kelley, Select Board Member

Newly seated member Chris Rohland cast the deciding vote in favor of Langill, citing Langill’s experience managing Weymouth’s $227 million budget as key preparation for Marshfield’s operations. The appointment passed 2-1, subject to background checks and contract negotiations. The Board expressed its deep appreciation to Interim Town Administrator Peter Morin for his over 15 months of dedicated service to the municipality.

Moving to structural governance, the Board voted 2-1 (Kelley dissenting) to petition the state legislature for two town charter changes previously approved by voters at Special Town Meeting:

1. Expanding the Select Board: Expanding the Board from three to five members.

2. Creating a Finance Director Position: Establishing a dedicated Director of Finance role. (Town Counsel noted this charter amendment will also require a town-wide ballot vote following legislative approval).

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Guided by Assistant Town Manager Lauren Lind, the workshop served as the second installment in a series designed to translate findings from a town-wide SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) analysis and the recently approved comprehensive plan into actionable municipal policies.

A central focus of the discussion was the ongoing pressure on Plymouth’s commercial and industrial land footprint. Lind and board members noted that while the town faces pressing housing needs, allowing residential development to encroach on light industrial zones undermines the non-residential tax base and risks future land-use conflicts. Lind explained that municipal staff are working with the Planning Board to update zoning definitions for commercial corridors, specifically aiming to refine mixed-use standards so that commercial vitality is preserved on the ground floor.

To address long-standing public perceptions regarding local regulatory hurdles, staff recommended establishing a designated “business concierge” within Town Hall. This cross-functional position would serve as a single point of contact to guide small business owners and developers through multi-departmental permitting workflows.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

The joint meeting opened with significant procedural and financial updates on the new South Shore Tech facility project. Project managers from OPM LeftField and general contractor Suffolk Construction presented an update on a recent Conservation Commission (ConCom) cease-and-desist order caused by unauthorized subcontractor vehicular traffic through a wetland crossing area near the Main Street lot. Following site evaluations with independent conservation scientists, restorative planning, and ongoing coordination, officials confirmed that the ConCom officially lifted the order, allowing site work to resume with no delay to the critical August 17th foundation pouring target. Furthermore, project officials confirmed that none of the remediation costs or fines were passed on to the district or building budget.

On the financial front, project leadership delivered highly encouraging news regarding sub-contractor bidding. The district received roughly 60 bids across 14 trade categories. Project representatives noted that bidding market conditions were exceptionally competitive and favorable, with incoming figures coming in below budget expectations across all trade categories.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

The joint meeting brought long-standing friction between town administration and the elected Light Board over facility planning to a head. Light Board members Jacob Vaillancourt and Tom Burns presented a conceptual proposal to keep operations at 15 Edgewater Road, citing historical significance, lower overall costs, and a desire to maintain independent utility operations.

Town Manager Jennifer Constable countered that extensive professional engineering studies funded by state grants had already evaluated site vulnerabilities, recommending a $45 million flood-resilient joint facility at 9 Nantasket Ave—of which the Light Plant’s share would be $14.4 million prior to potential federal BRIC grant offsets. Constable emphasized that under the town charter, the town manager oversees municipal facilities and grant applications, warning that split operations or local historical designations could restrict site redevelopment and inflate municipal costs.

Select Board members expressed divergent views on authority, project costs, and utility needs. Select Board Member Jerry Taverna voiced strong opposition to committing taxpayer resources toward a $45 million to $60 million joint building complex when the Light Board overwhelmingly preferred to remain at its current location and repair existing assets. Conversely, Select Board Member Greg Grey urged caution, arguing that the town charter establishes the Light Board as an advisory body on administrative matters and that the board should not bypass established administrative planning or turn down regional grant opportunities.

Ultimately, the Select Board voted 3-2 to direct the town manager to remove HMLP from the pending Phase 4 CZM grant application and voted 3-2 to direct the Light Plant Manager to move forward with HMLP’s $110,000 feasibility study for 15 Edgewater Road.

“The point is not opposition to the joint facility; it’s a request to study both paths to the same standard so the more resilient and affordable choice can be identified, not assumed.” — Jacob Vaillancourt, Hull Municipal Light Board Member

Read more

The public aspects of the dispute emerged in late July 2026, following a sequence of closed-door administrative actions that occurred earlier in the month. The Stoughton Select Board, the town’s elected executive governing body, has positioned itself as an impartial adjudicator and scheduled a meeting on Wednesday, July 29, 2026, to determine how the town will independently investigate complaints filed against both officials.

This article provides an objective, chronological reconstruction of the standoff, an overview of the key officials, an analysis of the structural charter ambiguities at the center of the legal dispute, and an examination of the upcoming Select Board proceedings.

Subscribe now

The July 2026 Timeline: How the Dispute Developed

The current administrative impasse developed rapidly over a three-week period in July 2026:

• June 2026: Chief McNamara formally notified Town Manager Calter that she was actively cooperating with federal investigators and anticipated that additional internal affairs investigations might be necessary as the federal murder case against former Stoughton detective Matthew Farwell progressed.

• July 7, 2026: Town Manager Thomas Calter, accompanied by a town labor attorney, met with Police Chief Donna McNamara at Town Hall. According to McNamara’s legal counsel, Attorney Leah Barrault, Calter informed McNamara that a complaint had been made against her. He did not disclose the identity of the complainant or the specific allegations. Barrault states that Calter told McNamara she must either resign or face termination, and instructed her not to report to work. Calter later confirmed in an interview that he “had to separate her from the department” but declined to comment on the underlying reasons.

• July 9, 2026: A follow-up meeting between Calter and McNamara was scheduled, but it was canceled. Calter stated that McNamara canceled the meeting, while McNamara’s counsel noted she was never formally placed on administrative leave.

• July 20, 2026: Chief McNamara filed a formal harassment complaint against Town Manager Calter with the Stoughton Select Board. The complaint accused Calter of engaging in a pattern of gossip, trying to damage her reputation, and calling and texting her personal cell phone nearly daily over a two-week period. Her attorney characterized these actions as a gender-based attempt to force the chief out of her position. Calter acknowledged contacting McNamara during this period but disputed the frequency of the contacts.

• July 22, 2026: The town administration released a statement announcing that Deputy Police Chief James O’Connor had been appointed Acting Police Chief. McNamara’s attorney publicly responded, stating that McNamara had not resigned, retired, or voluntarily stepped away, and had only learned of her replacement through media reports. Barrault described the appointment as a constructive discharge and a breach of the chief’s employment contract.

• July 23, 2026: Dozens of residents attended a Select Board meeting to express support for McNamara, chanting for her return before the board entered an executive session with counsel. Two of the five Select Board members were absent, and no formal votes were taken.

• July 24, 2026: The Select Board issued an official press release confirming that it was processing two separate, concurrent personnel complaints—one filed by McNamara against Calter, and another unspecified complaint involving Chief McNamara that had been brought to the town’s attention. The board stated it had reached no conclusions and committed to a “fair, thorough, and impartial” independent review.

• Sunday, July 26, 2026: Hundreds of supporters gathered for a public rally in downtown Stoughton to demand McNamara’s immediate reinstatement.

• Monday, July 27, 2026: Chief McNamara filed her formal lawsuit in Norfolk Superior Court, detailing the specific allegations behind her ouster. That evening, Town Manager Calter broke his silence, denying all accusations of sexism and harassment in an interview with the Boston Globe.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Representatives from SAIL Homes—a non-profit organization dedicated to providing Supported Access to Independent Living for adults with autism and intellectual development disabilities—presented their successful residential project in Scituate and discussed potential future collaboration with Norwell. Executive Director Marynell Henry and co-founder Wendy Ellison detailed how their Scituate facility retrofitted an existing commercial building into three specialized apartments serving eight residents.

The model relies heavily on embedded assistive technology, including virtual monitoring platforms and smart household systems, allowing adults to live semi-independently without requiring full-time on-site caregivers. Funding for the Scituate project combined philanthropic donations, Community Preservation Act (CPA) housing funds, and state earmarks. Board members expressed strong interest in exploring similar opportunities in Norwell, noting potential synergy with the town’s Village Residential Overlay District and local housing trusts.

“Over 70% [of adults with autism] are living at home with aging caregivers... As a parent, my husband and I lay awake at night saying, ‘Who is going to take care of our son? Where is he going to live?’” [18:00] — Marynell Henry, Executive Director & Co-Founder, SAIL Homes

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Town Administrator Jim Boudreau opened his administrative report with critical news regarding municipal finances. FEMA notified the town that it is abandoning multiple legacy disaster declaration grants dating back as far as 2012, including projects along Third Cliff. According to Boudreau, the federal agency cited extensive permitting delays—despite past assurances urging the town to proceed—and is now demanding reimbursement or withholding roughly $3 million in anticipated project funding.

The decision not only forces Scituate to cover the direct project costs but also threatens to create cash deficits on the town’s financial books where federal receipts had been anticipated. Scituate is reaching out to state officials, federal legislative delegations, and seven other Massachusetts coastal communities facing identical federal clawbacks to organize a collective response. Select Board members expressed sharp frustration over the sudden policy shift, noting that lengthy multi-year state and federal environmental permitting processes placed the town in an impossible double bind.

“FEMA has been telling us to keep going and now the time is, ‘Well, sorry. We don’t care. We told you to keep going, we’re going to take back the money that you spent.’ So this could be impactful... It also underscores the fact that the state and feds are going to have to make some changes to how they permit repair projects. It should not take 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 years to permanently repair a structure.” — Jim Boudreau, Town Administrator

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Assistant Town Administrator Katie Dugan presented the roadmap for the upcoming Special Town Meeting, detailing how the town plans to address urgent infrastructure needs while taking advantage of state grants.

The first two warrant articles center on full borrowing authorizations for roof replacement projects at Plymouth River Elementary School (PRS) and South Elementary School. Both projects were accepted into the Massachusetts School Building Authority (MSBA) Accelerated Repair Program in December 2025, which offers a 36.89% matching grant for eligible costs. Following schematic design submissions at the end of August, the MSBA is scheduled to vote on project approval on October 28. Under MSBA rules, municipalities must secure full borrowing authorization within 90 days of state approval.

A third article from the 2025 School Building Committee requests a scope adjustment—without asking for new money—for the $3.3 million High School feasibility and schematic design authorization approved at the 2025 Annual Town Meeting. The revision would allow the committee to spend approximately $1 million in remaining funds from January through April 2027 on pre-construction services, construction documents, and early bid packages. Because the original authorization was funded through borrowing, the scope revision requires a two-thirds majority vote.

The fourth article reintroduces a $70 million borrowing authorization for the Hingham Municipal Lighting Plant (HMLP) to fund transmission and substation distribution facility improvements. Originally withdrawn at the 2026 Annual Town Meeting, the measure returns as state siting approvals wrap up in August. Dugan clarified that because HMLP operates as an enterprise utility, debt service will be paid through ratepayer revenues rather than property taxes.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

The Plymouth Select Board held its off-site “Town Hall on the Road” meeting in North Plymouth, providing residents a direct forum with board members and Town Manager Derek Brindisi. Highlighting the evening were discussions regarding major infrastructure initiatives, local school building studies, traffic safety, and the contentious Pulte Chapter 40B housing development.

At the outset of the meeting, the board briefly debated Administrative Note #1 regarding personnel code amendments. Select Board Member Bill Keohan raised concerns over voting on reclassifications while a town-wide compensation study remains underway. Town Manager Derek Brindisi clarified that the proposed changes included reclassifying the Community Preservation Committee (CPC) coordinator position from grade A5 to A6 and shifting seasonal treasurer-collector staff to non-union roles following bargaining with SEIU. Brindisi noted that the town-wide study is expected to wrap up by the end of fall. To allow for further evaluation of position percentages and pay steps, the board voted unanimously to defer action on the item.

During the Town Manager’s Report, Brindisi provided updates on critical North Plymouth issues:

• Pulte Development Infrastructure Obligations: Pulte has agreed to several infrastructure improvements, including reconfiguring the end of Prince Street with a standard turnaround, installing a looped water main between Prince Street and Hedge Road, placing an emergency warning beacon at Hedge Road and Court Street, and establishing a connection to the North Plymouth Rail Trail. However, Brindisi cautioned that all Pulte improvements remain on hold pending the outcome of ongoing legal appeals regarding the Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) decision.

• Cherry Street & Court Street Intersection / Water Main: The town executed a contract to replace the aging, break-prone water main on Cherry Street, with work slated to start this fall, pause for the winter due to surface bypass lines, and complete in the spring. Furthermore, Eversource plans to replace a main on Cherry Street crossing into Prince Street. The major intersection improvements at Cherry Street, Court Street, and Prince Street—budgeted at approximately $2.5 million—are projected for summer or fall 2027 to avoid tearing up newly paved roads after utility work.

• Hedge & Cold Spring School Feasibility Study: The Massachusetts School Building Authority (MSBA) accepted Hedge Elementary School into its feasibility study stage with an estimated 53% state reimbursement, exploring potential consolidation with Cold Spring Elementary. An Owner’s Project Manager (OPM) contract has been executed, and an architectural firm selection is underway, to be followed by robust public outreach meetings this fall.

• North Plymouth Fire Station: Following failed negotiations with prior top bidders, the town is pursuing state funding for a Phase 2 site assessment to remediate soil and building hazardous material contamination before repurposing the structure.

• Traffic & Pedestrian Upgrades: DPW added 28 crosswalk/pedestrian signs along Court Street, installed bump-outs at Standish and Alden Street, and added flashing pedestrian signs near Christ the King Parish at Allerton Street.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

During a lengthy July 21 meeting, board members debated a proposed compromise to break a stalemate over the Whitman-Hanson Regional School District agreement. Under the proposal outlined by Select Board member Frank Milisi, Hanson would agree to shift non-mandated busing costs into the district’s operating budget starting in Fiscal Year 2028. The shift is estimated to add approximately $54,000 to $65,000 annually to Hanson’s educational costs due to regional assessment formulas.

In return, the district would implement a policy requiring a two-thirds majority vote of the full School Committee for major administrative, financial, and policy decisions. That threshold would grant Hanson representatives a functional veto on critical matters, including regional agreement amendments, capital debt incurrence, superintendent employment contracts, grade reconfigurations, school closures, land/building leases, and major litigation settlements.

While board members generally backed the strategic trade-off, several raised concerns about potential loopholes and requested a comprehensive review by town legal counsel and DESE before formalizing the deal and sending it to Town Meeting.

“What we’re gaining on that is the understanding that in order for them to make any decisions based on these list of items here … there can be no more town line votes at that point.” — Frank Milisi, Hanson Select Board Member

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Municipal administrative errors took center stage when the board, convening as Water and Sewer Commissioners, reviewed an astronomical $42,239.88 water bill issued to West Street homeowner Nigel Bird. Water and Sewer Superintendent Mark Cloud explained that following an investigation, town staff discovered the home’s original meter reading had recorded incorrectly and dropped to zero years ago following radio replacements, inadvertently tallying 22 years of cumulative town water usage onto a single recent bill. Bird detailed his five-week ordeal performing forensic accounting across two decades of land records to prove he had not consumed 4 million gallons of water—equivalent to filling 200 swimming pool. The board unanimously granted an abatement reducing his balance to $892.02.

“If you’re going to give somebody a $43,000 bill, you’ve got to be damn sure that they used that water in all the history... It turns out it was ultimately a town problem.” [01:07:08] — Nigel Bird, Resident

A second abatement request on Bay Road involving 451,000 gallons of unaccounted water usage was tabled for further data collection after homeowner Rebecca Marani presented quarterly bills showing usage spiked drastically prior to a meter replacement in December 2025 and immediately normalized thereafter. Board members expressed concern over recurring townwide meter and radio malfunctions, prompting plans for a comprehensive departmental review with DPW leadership.

Public comment opened with sharp exchanges regarding the future of the Powder Point Bridge. Resident Alicia Babcock challenged the Selectboard’s timeline, calling for immediate action to file a Section 106 historical preservation review and support community efforts against MassDOT’s demolition and replacement proposal. Town Manager René Read clarified that a scheduled advisory recommendation was postponed pending a formal response from MassDOT addressing nine specific technical and financial inquiries submitted by the town. Resident Dick Brennan countered that the board should take all necessary time to evaluate the long-term financial consequences for taxpayers.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

During a streamlined summer agenda, the committee formally adopted second readings for key school policies and the district athletic handbook, approved staff dependent enrollments, and reviewed the first reading of the updated School Committee Resource Guide. Committee members praised the resource document for helping navigate municipal oversight and aligning with state-level school committee guidance.

Superintendent Matt Keegan presented an extensive overview of the leadership team’s recent retreat and his annual evaluation artifact review. Key operational focus areas for the upcoming academic year include multi-tiered system of supports (MTSS) behavioral frameworks, Universal Design for Learning (UDL) professional development, high school accreditation alignment, and financial planning.

In district facilities updates, administrative leaders outlined the next phase of the Massachusetts School Building Authority (MSBA) partnership. Following entry into the feasibility study phase earlier this year, the district received responses to its Request for Services (RFS) for an Owner’s Project Manager (OPM) on July 15. The OPM Selection Committee is actively interviewing and ranking applicants, with a recommendation expected to be presented to the full School Building Committee later in the week ahead of final state approval in September.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

The Marshfield Select Board met for a brief evening session on July 20, 2026, opening with praise for local public safety personnel. Board members commended the Marshfield Police Department, Marshfield Fire Department, and regional partner agencies for their coordinated management of the annual Levitate Music & Arts Festival. Chair Rick Smith and Select Board Member Eric Kelley highlighted the success of the Mobile Operations Command Center and noted that public safety and traffic routing executed smoothly throughout the multi-day event

After a brief executive session regarding potential real property acquisition and negotiations under Mass. General Law Chapter 30A, Section 21(a)(6), the board returned to open session at 7:18 p.m. to act on several financial and administrative items.

The board formally accepted three sets of local donations benefiting town departments:

• Veterans Services: A $100 contribution from Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Hanlon to assist local veterans with health, welfare, and emergency financial needs.

• Council on Aging: Seven separate memorial donations totaling $850 given in memory of resident James Fox to support senior programs.

• Marshfield Historical Commission: An anonymous $3,000 gift to support historic preservation work across town.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

In a joint session with sole Abington Water Commissioner Amanda Hunter, the Select Board addressed critical vacancies on the joint Abington-Rockland Water Commission. Hunter highlighted that with three seats filled on Rockland’s side and only one on Abington’s, filling the two open seats was essential to maintain quorums and ensure balanced municipal representation.

The board interviewed three candidates present: tech consultant Zachary McGovern, licensed master plumber Corey Dalton, and retired Coast Guard Lieutenant Richard Mullen. When questioned about addressing town water supply challenges and potential water regionalization options, candidates discussed analyzing system throughput, monitoring population and commercial growth demands, and exploring potential regional water connections.

Hunter voiced strong support for Dalton, pointing out the value of having a candidate with licensed plumbing expertise to evaluate technical maintenance issues. Following motions, the joint body appointed Corey Dalton on a 4-1 vote and unanimously appointed Richard Mullen to serve on the commission. Hunter also updated the board that Abington’s PFAS water treatment plant is making great progress and is currently online.

Read more

According to preliminary results, Rohland captured nearly 69% of the vote in a three-way contest, surging past candidates Jack Griffin and Joe Pecevich.

Subscribe now

Final Tally:

• Chris Rohland: 2,477 votes (68.4%)

• Jack Griffin: 959 votes (26.5%)

• Joe Pecevich: 185 votes (5.1%)

Rohland, a former Select Board member and current Advisory Board member, ran on a platform focused on ending administrative gridlock, filling the long-vacant Town Administrator position, and allowing residents a ballot vote on the town’s proposed budget override.

His overwhelming win breaks a months-long board impasse, restoring the Select Board to its full three-member capacity alongside members Eric Kelley and Rick Smith.

Subscribe now

Marshfield at the Breaking Point

The Marshfield special election crystallized a choice that many South Shore towns are quietly approaching but haven’t yet been forced to make explicit: do you go to the ballot or go to the spreadsheet?

• Marshfield — Empty Seat and Divergent Paths: Candidates Face Off Over Marshfield’s $5 Million Deficit Chris Rohland backed an immediate Prop 2½ override of up to $7 million as a democratic obligation following Town Meeting’s directive; Joe Pecevich countered that a $500,000 cherry-sheet adjustment and alleged school-side accounting errors make the underlying numbers untrustworthy, and called for zero-based budgeting instead — while the absence of third candidate Jack Griffin, who skipped both forums and was spotted at a campaign meet-and-greet the same night, drew sharp condemnation from moderator Christine James: “He basically blew us off. I don’t like being lied to.”

• Marshfield — Marshfield School Committee Unanimously Approves Three Collective Bargaining Agreements, Forestalls Sub-Varsity Sports Cuts The School Committee ratified contracts with the teachers and nurses, assistant principals, and tutors units, and confirmed that $80,000 in athletics administrative restructuring savings will spare freshman and JV sports — though Superintendent Dr. Patrick Sullivan noted the district remains in a “structural holding pattern” until the Select Board is seated and can decide whether to put an override on the ballot; a state budget that came in $445,000 above town revenue projections, with more than $300,000 in additional Chapter 70 aid, provided a partial cushion.

Override Arithmetic: Fiscal Stress Across the Region

The year-end closeout season is sorting towns into two camps: those that planned for surprise and absorbed it, and those that are raiding reserves to stay solvent.

• Hingham — Hingham Secures Balanced Budget as Year-End Transfers Come In $1 Million Under Forecast The Select Board approved $1.7 million in FY26 reserve fund transfers — a full million below Town Meeting’s authorization — driven by $600,000 in SPED out-of-placement savings, $400,000 in operational efficiencies, and a $296,234 supplemental snow-and-ice aid injection secured through Senator Patrick O’Connor, with the unused balance rolling back into fund balance.

• Plympton — Fennessey Appointed Permanent Plympton Town Administrator in Split 2-1 Vote Amid Looming $317K Year-End Deficit The Board of Selectmen voted 2-1 to make interim Robert Fennessey permanent — Chairman Sides dissenting in favor of a candidate with deeper municipal finance credentials — even as Town Accountant Lisa disclosed a $317,283.55 year-end deficit driven by a $128,000 police salary overage and a $78,741.67 legal budget blowout, closed out only by raiding group health insurance surpluses, the transfer station account, and the reserve fund.

• Pembroke — Pembroke School Committee Relinquishes Hatch Building Jurisdiction, Solidifies FY26 Budget Surplus A deliberate mid-year personnel freeze that left positions unfilled due to shallow applicant pools generated enough year-end savings to fund all planned FY27 technology and curriculum purchases and still return $220,000 to the town toward its snow-and-ice deficit — plus a separate $46,311 from liquidated purchase orders — while the committee voted 4-0 to transfer jurisdiction of the historic Hatch building to the Select Board, shedding maintenance liability and unlocking eligibility for historic preservation grants.

Water: A Region Running Out of Margin

The week’s most consequential infrastructure story isn’t about a single town — it’s about a regional system approaching multiple simultaneous limits.

• Hanover — Hanover Explores Long-Term MWRA Water Regional Pipeline and Fast-Tracks Critical Well Replacement A regional consortium study projects a combined 2.1-million-gallon-per-day peak deficit across a cluster of South Shore towns, with Hanover facing an immediate 400,000 GPD systemic shortfall if its single highest-producing well pump fails on a holiday weekend; the proposed fix — a 8-to-13-mile transmission main piggybacking on Weymouth’s MWRA pipeline — carries a total cost north of $100 million, with Hanover’s share completely unnegotiated and heavily dependent on whether intermediate towns like Abington and Rockland commit.

• Whitman — Whitman Faces Ceiling on Sewer Capacity Agreement as Upcoming Projects Loom Whitman’s 365-million-gallon annual sewer contract with Brockton — which rejects expansion requests due to its own DEP limits — is being consumed from below: in-progress construction already adds roughly 19 million gallons to a 320-million-gallon baseline, leaving almost no room for a proposed 254-unit complex at 66 Pond Street and a 52-unit development at 185 Franklin Street before daily overages trigger penalties starting at $5,000 to $10,000 per day.

• Regional / Duxbury — What’s in the Water: A South Shore News Investigation A first-in-series investigation of 22 South Shore water systems finds that Consumer Confidence Report compliance is a rolling average, not a real-time guarantee — with Duxbury’s shuttered Partridge Road well posting PFAS6 readings up to 142 ppt in the state database while in-service wells stay under 10 ppt, Norwell formally in violation at its Washington Street entry point and running a bottle-filling station, and Hanover and Middleborough having exceeded PFAS6 limits at active sources.

• Halifax — PFAS Funds and Citizen Petitions Shape Upcoming Halifax Special Town Meeting The Select Board voted to close the warrant for a July 29 Special Town Meeting whose two board-sponsored articles would rescind the ATM vote placing PFAS settlement funds in a standard two-thirds-supermajority stabilization account and reauthorize the money in a vehicle the Water Commissioners can deploy directly.

School Budgets Under Pressure

Districts are tightening compensation structures and shedding facilities obligations — signals that the pressure on salary lines is not letting up even as fiscal years close.

• Hanover — Hanover School Committee Ratifies Agreement to Limit Alternative Non-Academic Coursework for Teacher Pay Raises In a unanimous vote, the School Committee ratified an MOA with the Hanover Teachers Association requiring all future lane-change coursework to apply toward a graduate degree at an accredited institution, with prior principal approval and a new joint review committee to police commercial online PD credits — while grandfathering teachers already mid-course.

• Hingham — Hingham School Committee Gives Superintendent Top Marks as MTSS Data Shows Strong Elementary Growth The committee unanimously rated Superintendent Dr. Katie Roberts “exemplary” in instructional leadership, management, and family engagement — praising her navigation of severe budget constraints — while MTSS data showed third- and fourth-grade special education cohorts outpacing general education growth rates at 158%–194% of state-standard targets, even as middle school SPED gaps widened.

• Plymouth — Plymouth School Committee Overhauls Advertising Rules and Moves Forward with $800K Fundraising Report A policy revision delegating corporate sponsorship approval from the full committee to the superintendent triggered a heated debate over oversight and reputational risk, ultimately resolved by adding language requiring all advertisers to align with district “mission, vision, and values” — a modified draft heading back to subcommittee before the August session.

  Share

Development and Redevelopment

Two stories this week illustrate the wide range of tools towns are deploying to move stalled assets — one a decades-delayed surplus school building sale, the other a contentious private-road policy intended to stop a $36 million liability from accumulating further.

• Abington — $2M Deal Secured for Closed Abington North and Center Schools Causeway Development will acquire both 1938–1939 Art Deco school buildings “as is” for approximately $2 million, using historic tax credits, MBTA funding, and affordable housing grants to convert them into 56 units of mixed affordable housing — projected to generate $350,000 to $400,000 annually in new tax revenue per building — with the DPW slated to vacate by Thanksgiving and the developer unable to take formal possession until April 2027.

• Plymouth — Plymouth Select Board Approves Strict New Road Acceptance Policy Despite Shallow Pond Outlier Plea A 3-2 vote locked in a policy requiring petitioning residents to cover 100% of upgrade costs via betterment assessments before town acceptance of the 133 miles of private ways currently on the books — immediately tested by Shallow Pond Estates, whose 35-year-old petition ran into a title-defect problem spanning roughly 180 parcels and preliminary resolution costs estimated at $90,000–$144,000 before legal fees.

• Hanson — Hanson Green-Lights Long-Awaited Hubble Conservation Purchase, Reverses Course on Affordable Housing Buyout After nearly three years in limbo, Hanson closed on 45 acres off Hawks Avenue from Hubble Distribution for $117,500; separately, the board rescinded its right of first refusal on an affordable condo at Dunham Farms and aired sharp frustration over being treated as a “cash cow” in the Whitman-Hanson school funding agreement.

County Government in the Spotlight

• Plymouth County — Heated Plymouth County GOP Forum Sparks Clashes Over Commissioner Pay, Federal ARPA Funds, and Governance Challenger Tony O’Brien attacked incumbent Sandra Wright’s $40,000 stipend and up to $25,000 in annual health benefits as “$3,000-per-hour self-profiting,” while Wright countered that she inherited a $1 million deficit and state abolishment threats in 2011 and has built a $1.5 million surplus with zero debt; candidate Korey Welch accused Wright of a “uniparty alliance” with the board’s lone Democrat, and all three clashed over whether keeping $200 million in ARPA and CARES Act money at the county level — rather than surrendering it to the state — was sound stewardship or reckless federal liability.

Public Safety and Local Licensing

• Marshfield — High-Tech “Self-Pour” Beer & Wine System Paused Over Youth Safety Concerns The Select Board voted 2-0 to continue a public hearing for Train4Life’s wine-and-malt license to August 3, directing the applicant to meet with Police Chief Phil Tavares after members balked at an Amazon facial-recognition-powered automated dispensing system operating unsupervised one floor above a gym frequented by teenagers — Board Chair Rick Smith stating he would not support the license without a TIPS-certified employee physically present on the premises.

• Halifax — Halifax Beach Debacle Prompts Security Lockout and Land Ownership Investigation After out-of-town jet ski groups coordinated enforcement workarounds on social media and overwhelmed a beach where the lone Parks Commissioner was hauling trash in his personal truck, the Select Board voted unanimously to reinstall a blocking gate at the 4th Avenue ramp through September 7 while launching a title search to determine who actually owns the waterfront.

• East Bridgewater — Federal Funds Bring Automated License Plate Readers to East Bridgewater Four Flock Safety cameras funded entirely by $30,000 in FBI task force asset forfeiture funds will roll out within six to eight weeks, integrating with CJIS and NCIC and sharing data with Hanson, Weymouth, Abington, and Bridgewater — at zero cost to the local tax levy.

• Cohasset — Faltering Line Paint Sparks Public Safety Showdown Over Sandy Beach Parking Lot An $8,500 emergency restriping request for Sandy Beach — where deteriorated markings are blocking fire engines and ambulances on peak summer days and unsealed cracks risk piping plover nesting that would force mandatory closures — was tabled by the Advisory Committee, which demanded DPW solve what it called an ongoing failure of operational budgeting before any emergency appropriation.

Municipal Housekeeping

• Pembroke — Pembroke Select Board Approves Bylaw Committee Overhaul and Sets Fall Special Town Meeting Timeline The Select Board unanimously overhauled the General Bylaw Review Committee’s structure — moving from one-year to staggered three-year terms to prevent wholesale membership turnover — and set the Fall Special Town Meeting warrant window from 8 a.m. August 10 to noon August 14.

• Kingston — Early Voting Approved for State Primaries in Kingston Despite Dissent The Board of Selectmen voted 3-1 to authorize an early voting precinct at the Townhouse for August 22–28, with Chair Kimberley Emberg casting the dissenting vote on grounds that absentee access already duplicates the utility; separately, Conservation Agent Matt Penella announced a $1.6 million match-free MassDOT grant for the Lake Street Culvert project, slated for summer 2027.

• Rockland — Redesigns Keep New $26.1M Rockland Fire Station on Budget After Initial Overruns A 1,000-square-foot reduction — dropping a conference room and substituting standard overhead bay doors for deep bifolding ones — pulled the fire headquarters back under the $26.1 million cap after an independent cost estimator flagged regional bidding-climate risk, with the board unanimously approving exterior signage details and a corner watchtower designed to echo the demolished Lincoln School’s historical profile.

• Hanover — Hanover Select Board Approves Multi-Year Contracts for Police and Fire Leadership Four-year salary agreements lock in the deputy fire chief (from $156,560 in FY26 to $168,598 in FY29) and police lieutenant (from $159,392.50 to $171,648.29), plus a new three-year firefighters union MOU — committing Hanover to a known compensation runway through FY29.

Looking Ahead

• Marshfield special election — Saturday, July 25

• Halifax Special Town Meeting — July 29

• Pembroke Fall Special Town Meeting — warrant opens 8 a.m. August 10; closes noon August 14.

  South Shore News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

In Duxbury, the cost of PFAS has a number, and residents are about to see it on their bills. The town’s own rate study projects the average household’s annual water bill climbing from about $379 in 2025 to $823 by 2028 — more than double, and Duxbury’s first rate increases since 2010. The money will help cover a $43 million treatment plant, the first of two the town needs to scrub PFAS, iron and manganese from its wells and bring its idled Depot Street source back online.

Duxbury is not an outlier. It is just further along in saying out loud what every water department on the South Shore is now working out: getting PFAS out of the water is going to cost a fortune, and somebody has to pay for it.

Across the region, the bills already on paper run past $200 million in PFAS treatment alone — Middleborough’s $80-million-plus plan, Duxbury’s $43 million, Hanover’s $32 million for three plants, Abington and Rockland’s $26 million, Norwell’s $18 million — and climb toward $350 million once you add the broader water-system overhauls PFAS is accelerating: Bridgewater’s $51.5 million capital plan, Scituate’s new $20 million treatment plant, Weymouth’s $35 million pivot to regional water. And Halifax is still costing its own plan out.

Subscribe now

Who pays: three buckets, and only one of them is uncapped

The money to fix this comes from three places. Two of them are limited. The third is you.

The companies that made it. PFAS didn’t appear in the aquifer by accident, and after years of litigation the manufacturers are paying into national settlements that fund water-system cleanup. 3M agreed to pay up to $10.3 billion over 13 years to public water systems; DuPont, Chemours and Corteva together added $1.185 billion. The money is parceled out system by system, by how contaminated a source is and how much water it produces — anywhere from a few hundred thousand dollars to tens of millions. (One Massachusetts town, Hudson, was told to expect about $2.9 million.) Halifax and Hanover have each confirmed receiving about $1 million so far — which appears to be the going rate for these small systems, and a modest sum against projects that run into the tens of millions.

But the money comes with a catch, and a clock. Water systems must file specific claims to collect — the DuPont fund’s deadline fell on June 30, 2026, the 3M fund’s on July 31 — and they must document their contamination source by source to qualify. Systems that miss the deadlines, or under-document, leave money on the table. Nationally, advocates have warned that hundreds of millions in settlement funds could go unclaimed.

The government. The state, using mostly federal infrastructure money, has been writing grants and cheap loans. MassDEP’s Emerging Contaminant program awarded $10.3 million to 18 water suppliers in April 2026, after $14.7 million to 21 suppliers earlier; it has set aside another $10 million to help systems plan and design treatment. And the state’s Drinking Water State Revolving Fund lends cheaply — the vehicle behind Abington and Rockland’s $26 million, interest-free loan, and Middleborough’s $33 million East Grove Street plant, which broke ground in August 2025 with a no-interest loan and 11 to 20 percent of the principal forgiven. Hanover is counting on up to $15 million in the same fund toward its $32 million project, plus small state grants — including a $25,000 Emerging Contaminant award for filter media. But even that is tightening: the state has said it can no longer offer zero-interest PFAS loans in 2026, steering other money toward partial forgiveness instead. As the cheap financing thins and the settlement deadlines pass, more of the cost slides toward the only bucket that can’t run dry.

The ratepayers. Whatever the settlements and grants don’t cover, your water bill does — and that is the bucket with no bottom. Take Hanover’s $32 million plan. About $1 million comes from the settlement and $25,000 from a state grant; the $15 million state loan still has to be paid back with interest. Strip out the roughly $1 million in genuinely outside money and ratepayers are on the hook for the rest — about 97 percent of the project, one way or another. It is the same arithmetic in every town, which is why Duxbury’s average bill is set to more than double by 2028.

And it lands hardest where there are the fewest people to spread it across. Many of these towns had held water rates flat for years — Duxbury since 2010, Halifax since 2015 — and PFAS is what finally broke the freeze.

The clock: 2029, maybe 2031

There’s a deadline driving the spending, and the federal rule it enforces works differently from the state’s. Instead of capping the sum of six PFAS compounds at 20 parts per trillion, it limits just two — PFOA and PFOS, individually, to 4 ppt each. The two aren’t a clean multiple of one another: a town whose contamination ran mostly through the other four compounds could, in theory, clear the federal bar while brushing the state limit. The compliance date is 2029; in May 2026 the EPA proposed letting systems request a two-year extension, to 2031, but that proposal is not yet final.

That theoretical loophole isn’t how the South Shore’s contamination breaks down. Here, PFOA and PFOS are the dominant compounds — and measured against the 4 ppt federal line, 16 of the 20 water systems already have one of the two above it in at least one treated source. Only Plymouth and Whitman’s Brockton-fed supply sit clearly under. So for these towns the federal limit is the binding one, and the towns comfortably “passing” the state standard today are, for the most part, on the same hook as the towns in violation — just with a few years’ head start before the 4 ppt rule forces their hand.

Read more

Subscribe now

The Full Story

Hosted by WATD 95.9 FM in partnership with PAC-TV, the forum featured 16-year incumbent Commissioner Sandra Wright of Bridgewater, former Commissioner Anthony “Tony” O’Brien, and candidate Korey Welch, a former Rockland Selectman and small business owner. The debate was moderated by WATD’s Christine James, alongside panelists Tom Gorman and Kevin Tocci.

A central focus of the debate was the issue of commissioner compensation. Challenger Tony O’Brien repeatedly cited a recent local media investigation claiming that county commissioners receive roughly $40,000 in annual stipend and up to $25,000 in healthcare benefits while only meeting once or twice per month, which he calculated as an effective rate of $3,000 to $5,000 per hour. O’Brien pledged to institute a full review and eliminate what he characterized as unearned self-enrichment at taxpayers’ expense.

“Your county leadership run by senior commissioner Commissioner Wright is paying themselves $3,000 per hour on its face. That is egregious self-profiting on the backs of hardworking law-abiding taxpaying citizens.” — Tony O’Brien [[26:08]]

Incumbent Sandra Wright vehemently defended her record, emphasizing that when she took office in 2011, Plymouth County faced a $1 million deficit, uncompleted audits, and threats of state abolishment. Wright noted that she previously worked five years at $7,200 annually while putting in up to 60 hours a week to restore municipal trust. She stated that Plymouth County now maintains a $1.5 million budget surplus with zero debt.

Candidate Korey Welch took a middle position regarding compensation, stating that the Plymouth County Advisory Board sets commissioner pay and that modern commissioner duties extend far beyond attending bi-weekly meetings. However, Welch leveled criticism at Wright over board governance, accusing her of forming a “uniparty alliance” with the lone Democrat on the three-member commission, plunging the body into internal turmoil. Wright responded that former political ties with fellow commissioner Jared Valenzola frayed after she sought the chairmanship for 2026, attributing the rift to political friction.

The management of CARES Act and American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds also drew intense debate. O’Brien gave the county’s handling of $200 million in federal relief an “F” grade, asserting that conservative Republicans should not support adding to federal debt and warning of potential liability if federal audits review local emergency expenditures. Both Wright and Welch strongly countered, arguing that by keeping administration at the county level rather than surrendering funds to the state, Plymouth County successfully delivered significantly more financial support directly to its 27 member communities at lower administrative cost.

Read more